GN 00210: Same-Sex Marriage Claims
TN 24 (02-16)
A. Recognition of same-sex marriages and non-marital legal relationships (NMLRs) established in foreign jurisdictions
Use the instructions in this section to determine the marital status of couples in same-sex marriages and same-sex NMLRs established in foreign jurisdictions.
1. Title II and Medicare
We recognize same-sex marriages and some NMLRs established in foreign jurisdictions as marriages for Title II and Medicare entitlement purposes.
To determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or a NMLR as a marriage established in a foreign jurisdiction, follow instructions GN 00210.006B in this section.
2. Title XVI
For Title XVI eligibility and payment amount purposes, we recognize same-sex marriages established in foreign jurisdictions. We recognize NMLRs established in foreign jurisdictions when one member of the couple is entitled to Title II benefits as the spouse of the other member of the couple. If a couple holds themselves out to the community as married, the couple is married for Title XVI purposes.
To determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or a NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction, follow instructions GN 00210.006C in this section.
For more information about determining marital status for purposes of Title XVI and holding out, refer to GN 00210.800 and SI 00501.152.
B. Steps to determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or a NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction for Title II and Medicare
Follow these steps to determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or a NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction.
Step |
Action |
---|---|
1 |
Marriage or NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction Does the claimant allege a same-sex marriage or NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction? A foreign jurisdiction, for Title II and Medicare, is somewhere other than:
If yes, go to step 2. If no, do not follow these instructions. Instead, refer to instructions for determining marital status for same-sex marriages or NMLRs established in a U.S. jurisdiction in GN 00210.002 and GN 00210.004. To determine marital status for opposite-sex couples, refer to GN 00305.005. |
2 |
Prior Non-marital legal relationship (NMLR) Does the claimant or number holder (NH) allege having established any prior NMLR with an individual other than his or her current spouse? If yes, check for an applicable precedent opinion in PR 05800.000. If no applicable precedent opinion exists, refer the case for a legal opinion on the possible effect of the prior relationship, using the instructions in GN 01010.815. Then, go to step 7. If no, go to step 3. |
3 |
Foreign Ceremonial marriage Did the couple allege having a foreign ceremonial same–sex marriage? If yes, obtain proof of marriage as set out below. Then, go to step 5. If no, go to step 4. Proof of marriage Use the following instructions to obtain proof of marriage:
|
4 |
Foreign non-ceremonial marriage (for example, common-law marriage), deemed marriage, or NMLR? Did the couple allege having a foreign non-ceremonial same-sex marriage (for example, common-law or other marriage according to local custom), a deemed marriage, or a NMLR? If yes, check for an applicable precedent opinion in PR 05800.000. If no applicable precedent opinion exists, refer the case for legal opinion, according to instructions in GN 01010.815. Then, go to step 7. NOTE: The opinion must address if the non-ceremonial marriage, deemed marriage, or NMLR was permitted in the foreign jurisdiction and recognized by the state of the NH's domicile (or the District of Columbia if domicile is in a foreign jurisdiction) to convey spousal inheritance rights. If no, the relationship is not recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title II and Medicare purposes. For claims, refer to processing instructions to deny the claim in GN 00210.020B. |
5 |
Marriage listed on table Did the couple establish a marriage in a foreign jurisdiction listed in the table in GN 00210.006D in this section? If yes, go to step 6. If no, and the couple established a marriage in a foreign jurisdiction not listed in the table, refer the case for legal opinion, according to instructions in GN 01010.815. Before you request a new legal opinion, check for an applicable precedent opinion in PR 05800.000. Then, go to step 7. |
6 |
Foreign jurisdiction marriage established Was the same-sex marriage established in a foreign jurisdiction on or after the date shown in Column II for when that foreign jurisdiction first permitted same-sex marriages? Refer to the table in GN 00210.006D in this section. If yes, for pending claims and post-entitlement actions, we will recognize the marriage as of the date it was established. Process the claim or post-entitlement action according to instructions in GN 00210.000. If no, the marriage is not recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title II and Medicare purposes. For claims, refer to processing instructions to deny the claim in GN 00210.020B. |
7 |
Recognition of the foreign marriage or NMLR – Legal opinion Does the legal opinion state that the claimant is in a valid foreign marriage, deemed marriage or NMLR that is recognized for purposes of determining entitlement under Title II and Medicare? If yes, process the claim or post-entitlement action following instructions in GN 00210.000. If no, the marriage or NMLR is not recognized as a marital relationship for Title II and Medicare purposes. For claims, refer to systems instructions to deny the claim in GN 00210.020B. |
C. Steps to determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or NMLR established in a foreign jurisdictions for Title XVI
Follow these steps to determine if we recognize a same-sex marriage or NMLR established in a foreign jurisdiction.
Step |
Action |
---|---|
1 |
Living with spouse and marriage celebrated in a foreign jurisdiction Does the claimant allege that he or she lives with someone of the same sex with whom he or she celebrated a ceremonial same-sex marriage in a foreign jurisdiction? For Title XVI purposes, a foreign jurisdiction is somewhere other than:
IMPORTANT: For Title XVI purposes, the following U.S. territories are foreign jurisdictions: American Samoa, Guam, Puerto Rico, and U.S. Virgin Islands. If yes, go to step 2. If no, develop for any of the following per GN 00210.800.
For opposite-sex couples, refer to SI 00501.150 and SI 00501.152. to determine marital status. |
2 |
Marriage listed on table Did the couple establish a marriage in a foreign jurisdiction listed in the table in GN 00210.006D in this section? If yes, go to step 3. If no, and the couple established a marriage in a foreign jurisdiction not listed in the table, check for an applicable precedent opinion in PR 05800.000. If no applicable precedent opinion exists, refer the case for legal opinion, according to instructions in GN 01010.815. Then go to step 4. |
3 |
Foreign jurisdiction marriage established Was the same-sex marriage established in a foreign jurisdiction on or after the date shown in Column II for when that foreign jurisdiction first permitted same-sex marriages? Refer to the table in GN 00210.006D in this section. If yes, the marriage is recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title XVI purposes. Process the claim or post-eligibility action following instructions in GN 00210.800. If no, the marriage is not recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title XVI purposes. Process the claim or post-eligibility action following instructions in GN 00210.800. |
4. |
Recognition of the foreign marriage – Legal opinion Does the legal opinion state that the claimant is in a valid foreign marriage that is recognized for purposes of determining eligibility under Title XVI? If yes, the marriage is recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title XVI purposes. Process the claim or post-eligibility action following instructions in GN 00210.800. If no, the marriage is not recognized as a valid marital relationship for Title XVI purposes. Process the claim or post-eligibility action following instructions in GN 00210.800. |
D. Chart for same-sex marriages established in a foreign jurisdiction
Consult this chart to determine the dates when foreign jurisdictions permitted same-sex marriages.
REMINDER: For Title XVI purposes, the following U.S. territories are foreign jurisdictions: American Samoa, Guam, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Column I |
Column II |
---|---|
Foreign Jurisdiction |
Date Same-Sex Marriages Were Permitted |
American Samoa |
June 26, 2015 |
Argentina |
July 21, 2010 |
Australia |
January 9, 2018 |
Austria |
January 1, 2019 |
Belgium |
June 1, 2003 |
Brazil |
May 14, 2013 |
Canada - Alberta, Prince Edward Island, Northwest Territories, Nunavut |
July 20, 2005 |
Canada - British Columbia |
July 8, 2003 |
Canada - Manitoba |
September 16, 2004 |
Canada - Newfoundland and Labrador |
December 21, 2004 |
Canada - New Brunswick |
July 4, 2005 |
Canada - Nova Scotia |
September 24, 2004 |
Canada - Ontario |
June 10, 2003 |
Canada - Saskatchewan |
November 5, 2004 |
Canada - Quebec |
March 19, 2004 |
Canada - Yukon |
July 14, 2004 |
England |
March 13, 2014 |
France |
May 17, 2013 |
Guam |
June 9, 2015 |
Ireland |
November 16, 2015 |
Netherlands |
April 1, 2001 |
Norway |
January 1, 2009 |
Puerto Rico |
June 26, 2015 |
South Africa |
November 30, 2006 |
Spain For marriages between a Spanish citizen and a non-Spanish national contracted between July 2, 2005 and October 26, 2005, refer the case for a legal opinion using the instructions in GN 01010.815. |
July 2, 2005 |
Sweden |
May 1, 2009 |
U.S. Virgin Islands |
June 26, 2015 |
E. References
GN 00303.700 United States (U.S.) Residency
GN 01010.255 Adjudication of Foreign Claims
GN 01010.410 Failure to Submit Essential Evidence
PR 05800.000 MARITAL RELATIONSHIP -- Same-Sex Relationships
RM 10212.050 Evidence of Name Change based on a Foreign Marriage or Foreign Same-Sex Marriage